All postsBrand Strategy

When Does Your Business Need a Brand Audit?

"Look First Change Later" in cream type on deep oxblood, beside a line drawing of brand touchpoints laid on a table, with a magnifying glass over one solid mustard square

Find out what your brand already owns before you spend money changing it.

A brand audit is a structured review of everything your brand puts into the world, measured against what it is meant to stand for. It shows you what is working, what has drifted and what is missing. You need one before a rebrand, before a big marketing push, and any time your team can no longer agree on which version of the logo is the real one.

What a brand audit is

Think of it as an inventory with an opinion. You gather every place your brand shows up, put it side by side, and judge each piece against three questions. Is it consistent with the rest? Is it recognizable? Is it still true to what the business does today?

Two terms help here. A touchpoint is any place a customer meets your brand: the sign, the box, the website, the invoice, the email signature, the way the phone is answered. Brand drift is the gap that opens slowly between the brand you designed and the brand people actually see. Nobody chooses drift. It builds up one reasonable decision at a time.

What it is not

An audit is not a rebrand. It is the step that tells you whether you need one. It is not a critique of a single ad or package, and it is not a marketing performance report, although performance data is useful evidence. The output is a clear picture and a short list of decisions, not new artwork.

When you need one

  • Before a rebrand or refresh. You cannot decide how much to change until you know what is worth keeping. (More on that choice in Rebrand or Refresh?.)
  • Before annual planning. New spend on a muddled brand makes the muddle louder.
  • After growth. New locations, product lines, partners or a merger all stretch a brand in different directions.
  • When the team argues about versions. If every new job starts with "which logo is right?", the brand has no agreed rules.
  • When customers describe you differently. If the way people talk about you no longer matches the way you talk about yourself, something has drifted.

What to look at

Group what you find into four areas.

  • Visual: logo versions, colour, typography, photography and illustration style.
  • Verbal: name, tagline, tone of voice, the words you use to describe what you do.
  • Experience: packaging, signage, website, social profiles, vehicles, uniforms, paperwork.
  • Perception: what customers, staff and partners actually say about you, in their own words.

For example, a craft brewery eight years into its range might find that the original mark still holds the shelf, while three different script typefaces have crept onto seasonal releases. The mark stays. Two of the scripts go. Nothing new was invented, and the range already looks more like itself.

How to run a brand audit: a checklist

  1. Gather everything. Print it, photograph it or screenshot it. Include the things you are embarrassed by.
  2. Lay it out side by side. A table or a wall works better than a folder. Drift is easier to see all at once.
  3. Mark what people recognize. Circle the assets customers would miss if they disappeared. These are your keepers.
  4. Find the drift. Note every variation in logo, colour, type and voice that nobody formally chose.
  5. Check the story. Does each piece reflect what the business does and believes now, or what it did five years ago?
  6. Ask outside the building. Talk to a handful of customers and partners. Ask what they would call you and why they chose you.
  7. Sort into keep, fix and retire. Be decisive. Most items land in keep or retire, not fix.
  8. Write the rules down. A short, usable set of guidelines stops the drift from starting again.

What to do with the results

Most audits point to one of three outcomes. A tidy: the brand is sound, it just needs rules and discipline. A refresh: the core holds, but some assets need modernizing. A rebrand: the brand no longer fits the business and the keepers list is short. Whichever it is, the audit tells you what must survive the change. Some assets should almost never move, and Which Brand Assets Should You Never Change? covers how to spot them.

The principle

Brands rarely need to be invented twice. Most need to be remembered. The equity you are looking for is usually already there, sitting in an old sign, a colour customers mention by name, or a line the founder wrote years ago. An audit is how you find it before you spend money replacing it.

If you would like a second set of eyes on yours, serifandgold.com is a good place to start.

Filed under: Brand Strategy

The Journal

Liked this? Get the next one.

New writing on brand and strategy, when there’s something worth saying.

Unsubscribe anytime.

Questions

What is a brand audit?

A brand audit is a structured review of everything your brand puts into the world, measured against what it is meant to stand for. It shows what is working, what has drifted and what is missing, and ends in a short list of decisions rather than new artwork.

When should a business do a brand audit?

Before a rebrand or refresh, before annual planning or a big marketing push, after growth such as new locations or product lines, and whenever the team can no longer agree on which version of the logo is the real one.

What does a brand audit look at?

Four areas: visual (logo versions, colour, typography, imagery), verbal (name, tagline, tone of voice), experience (packaging, signage, website, vehicles, paperwork) and perception (what customers, staff and partners actually say about you).

Is a brand audit the same as a rebrand?

No. An audit is the step that tells you whether you need a rebrand. Most audits point to a tidy (add rules and discipline), a refresh (modernize some assets) or a rebrand (the brand no longer fits the business).

Keep reading.

Who Should Own Your Brand Inside a Growing Business?Brand StrategyWhich Brand Assets Should You Never Change?Brand StrategyHow Do You Build a Personal Brand Inside a Brokerage Brand?Brand StrategyReal Estate Branding: How to Stand Out in the Most Crowded Category in MarketingBrand StrategyHow Do You Define Your Brand's Tone of Voice?StorytellingShould Your Brand Follow Design Trends?Identity + DesignWhat Does Your Ad Spend Say About Your Brand?Brand StrategyHow Do You Give Useful Feedback on Brand Design?Identity + DesignShould a New Product Get Its Own Brand Name, or Carry Yours?Brand StrategyShould You Fix Your Brand Before You Spend More on Marketing?Brand StrategyHow Do You Make a New Brand Look Established?Brand StrategyWhat Makes a Good Brand Name? A Practical Test for FoundersBrand StrategyHow to Choose Typefaces for Your BrandIdentity + DesignWhat Is a White-Label Creative Director? A Guide for Agency OwnersIndustry NotesRebrand or Refresh? How to Tell Which One Your Business NeedsBrand StrategyCraft Beverage Can Design: How to Build a Range That Grows Without BreakingCPG + PackagingWhat Does a Brand Strategy Actually Include?Brand Strategy"Make It Look More Premium" Is Not a BriefCPG + PackagingThe Handmade PremiumIdentity + DesignYour Brand Is Being Described By Machines NowIndustry NotesThe Category Is Shrinking. Your Brand Decision Just Got Harder.Industry NotesBranding: Credibility Meets InnovationBrand StrategyAgency Branding: Your First Impression Is Your Only ProofBrand StrategyHeritage Brand Modernization: The Real Risk Isn't Changing, It's Standing StillBrand StrategyCrafting Cohesive Logos and Brand Identity GuidelinesCPG + PackagingPackaging That Earns Its Shelf SpaceCPG + PackagingBrand Storytelling That Actually Does WorkStorytellingThe B2B Brand Messaging ProblemBrand StrategyHow to Design a Limited-Edition Can Without Losing Your BrandCPG + PackagingFrom Fruit Packer to Shelf Brand: Building Wild Coast Fruit Co.Identity + DesignHow Do You Build a Community Around a Craft Brewery?Brand Strategy