All postsStorytelling

Brand Storytelling That Actually Does Work

Illustration of a film projector unspooling a ribbon of film that shows an orchard at sunrise, a fruit picker, and a family sharing oranges at the table

Brand storytelling has been repeated into meaninglessness. Most of what gets called a brand story is an origin anecdote nobody asked for. A story earns its place when it makes a decision easier for the person hearing it.

Every brand has a founder story. Very few of them are worth telling.

The kitchen table. The recipe from a grandmother. The moment of frustration that sparked the idea. These are real, they are often genuinely meaningful to the founder, and they are almost never the reason anybody buys anything.

The confusion is understandable, because "brand storytelling" has been used to mean two completely different things. One is narrative craft in service of a commercial decision. The other is a founder's autobiography with better typography.

Only the first one does any work.

A brand story is not the story of your brand. It is the story that makes choosing you make sense.

What a story is actually for

Somebody is standing in front of a decision. They have incomplete information, several similar options, and limited appetite for research. A story does one of three things for them, and if it does none of them, it is decoration.

It explains why this exists. Not the origin - the reason. What is wrong with the alternatives, and what this was built to fix. This is the story that converts someone who did not know they had a problem.

It makes a claim believable. "Small batch" is a claim. The story of why the batch size is capped at four hundred litres and what happens to the flavour above that is proof. Stories are how abstract claims become credible.

It gives someone something to repeat. Word of mouth requires a sentence a person can carry. Nobody repeats a positioning statement. People repeat a story with a specific detail in it - the number, the place, the odd decision, the thing that sounds slightly unreasonable.

If your story is not doing at least one of those, it is taking up space that a product benefit could be using.

The three-part test

Before you commit to a narrative, run it through these.

1. Is it true in a way that is checkable? Not "we care about quality." Something a sceptic could verify. Specificity is the difference between a story and a mood, and it is also your defence when someone decides to test the claim.

2. Could a competitor say it? If yes, it is category language, not your story. Most brand narratives fail here. Every craft producer says they are obsessive about the process. The story is in the specific obsession, not the fact of one.

3. Does it survive compression? Your story will mostly be encountered in fragments - a label, a shelf talker, a fifteen-second video, a friend's summary. If it only works at eight hundred words, it does not work. Find the version that fits on a can.

Most narratives fail test two. A lot of good ones fail test three, which is why they read beautifully on the About page and vanish everywhere else.

Where the story actually lives

The About page is the least important place your story appears, and it is where most of the effort goes.

The story lives in:

The name. Often carrying more narrative weight than any paragraph you will write. Wild Coast Fruit Co. does more work than three sentences about Pacific origins, because the reader assembles the story themselves.

The product decisions. What you refused to do is frequently the most interesting part of the story, and it is the part competitors cannot copy without changing their business.

The packaging detail. A single line on the back of a pack, in the right voice, does more than a dedicated brand film. It is encountered at the moment of decision, by someone already holding the product. At Camp Beer Co., that detail was a QR code to the brewers who made it.

What the founder says off-script. The version told to a friend at a bar is usually three times better than the version on the website, because it has not been through legal, marketing and a stakeholder review that removed everything anyone might object to.

Field Note No. 03The Heritage AuditTen questions that uncover the history a brand already has, before anyone invents one.Read the Field Note

Consistency, not repetition

There is a real difference between telling the same story everywhere and telling the same truth everywhere.

Repetition is what makes audiences stop listening. The same eighty words on the website, the email footer, the trade sheet and the LinkedIn bio reads as a press release, and people have been trained to skim press releases.

Consistency means every touchpoint reflects the same underlying position, expressed appropriately for where it appears. The can gets one line. The trade sell sheet gets the version that matters to a buyer, which is usually about velocity and margin rather than heritage. The founder interview gets the long version with the detail that would not fit anywhere else.

Same truth, different depth. That is a brand with a story. The other thing is a brand with a paragraph.

From the studio

Open Access sells group retirement plans in a category that hides behind charts and products. The story it needed was not about the company. It was about the person the plan is for, shown as a split portrait: half an employee today, half someone like them at retirement. Picnic Creative wrote its story in four words in 2019, Telling the story of food, and built the mark around it. Seven years on, it still sits on the agency's home page.

The correction most brands need

If your story is currently about you - where you came from, what you believe, how you started - turn it around.

The strongest brand narratives are not about the brand at all. They are about the person buying, and the brand appears as the thing that resolves the situation they are in. Your origin story is at most the credibility that explains why you were the one to build it.

Nobody is waiting to hear about your kitchen table. They are trying to decide between two things on a shelf. Tell the story that makes that decision easy, and tell it in the number of words the shelf allows.

Serif + Gold finds the story that makes the decision easy, then fits it to the pack. Start with brand strategy or CPG packaging, or start a conversation at serifandgold.com.

Read next: How Do You Build a Community Around a Craft Brewery? and Heritage Brand Modernization.

Filed under: Storytelling

The Journal

Liked this? Get the next one.

New writing on brand and strategy, when there’s something worth saying.

Unsubscribe anytime.

Questions

What is brand storytelling?

Brand storytelling is narrative in service of a buying decision. A useful brand story explains why the product exists, makes a claim believable or gives people something specific to repeat. A founder's origin anecdote only counts if it does one of those jobs for the person deciding.

How do you know if a brand story is working?

Run three tests. Is it true in a way a sceptic could check? Could a competitor say the same thing? Does it survive compression onto a label, a shelf talker or a short video? Most brand stories fail the second test, and many good ones fail the third.

Where should a brand story appear?

Mostly outside the About page. The story lives in the name, the product decisions you refused to compromise on, a single line on the back of the pack and the way the founder tells it off-script. Those are the places people encounter it closest to the moment of decision.

Should a brand tell the same story everywhere?

Tell the same truth everywhere, not the same words. Repeating an identical paragraph across every channel reads like a press release. Consistency means each touchpoint reflects the same position at the right depth: one line on the can, buyer-focused detail on a sell sheet and the long version in an interview.